{
  "title": "Listen to Cuntz, with the evidence in view — Virtual Acoustic Objects",
  "text": "MODAVIS (2026). Listen to Cuntz, with the evidence in view — Virtual Acoustic Objects. Research notebooks, October 2026 · Interactive reuse and evidence edition. https://modavis.org/editions/2026-10-workbench/vao/listening-study/",
  "bibtex": "@misc{modavis_vao_listening_study_2026_10_workbench,\n  author = {{MODAVIS}},\n  title = {Listen to Cuntz, with the evidence in view — Virtual Acoustic Objects},\n  year = {2026},\n  month = {10},\n  version = {2026-10-workbench},\n  url = {https://modavis.org/editions/2026-10-workbench/vao/listening-study/},\n  note = {Content SHA-256: b3b6df9b9fa845599dfe6625e7f505b0812a3169324453fa71af6564f083ca02}\n}",
  "url": "https://modavis.org/editions/2026-10-workbench/vao/listening-study/",
  "sha256": "b3b6df9b9fa845599dfe6625e7f505b0812a3169324453fa71af6564f083ca02",
  "edition": "2026-10-workbench",
  "date": "2026-10-09",
  "canonicalPayload": "{\"book\":{\"number\":\"01\",\"slug\":\"vao\",\"title\":\"Virtual Acoustic Objects\"},\"chapter\":{\"blocks\":[{\"id\":\"listening-start\",\"text\":\"A recording, a representation and a research question\",\"type\":\"heading\"},{\"text\":\"A listening example becomes reusable when someone else can identify the exact file, understand how it was obtained, and see the limits of the interpretation. Start with a short audition and its amplitude envelope, then inspect the source and encoding details.\",\"type\":\"p\"},{\"attribution\":\"Recording, data curation, VAO production and maintenance: Dominik Ukolov; measurements: Philipp Hosbach; TASTEN and DISKOS coordination: Dr. Heike Fricke; project leadership: Prof. Dr. Josef Focht; restoration: Markus Brosig and Veit Heller; institution: Leipzig University; hosting: Musikinstrumentenmuseum der Universität Leipzig.\",\"audio\":{\"byteSize\":66378,\"sha256\":\"c5b4bb9e6e70d615df621b64a6052ca5bada5fa71666ea074423e7593389b104\",\"src\":\"/audio/cuntz-ged-036-c5b4bb9e6e70d615.ogg\"},\"boundary\":\"This is a recorded, encoded audition, not a certified reconstruction of how the organ sounded in 1610. Your playback device and room affect what you hear. The waveform is not calibrated sound pressure; it cannot establish acoustic fidelity, historical tuning, or the unresolved mapping between the physical and digital register inventories.\",\"context\":\"The dissertation describes acquisition at 192 kHz / 24 bit using a Neumann KM184 pair and RME Babyface Pro. This selected released mobile realization is Vorbis OGG at 48 kHz, stereo; its declared source master is a 192 kHz floating-point WAVE file. These encoding descriptions do not change the acquisition account.\",\"duration\":9.430666666666667,\"id\":\"cuntz-verified-listening\",\"intro\":\"Listen to the Gedackt mobile audition for control-note 36. This full 9.43-second file is one selected recording from the collection, presented alongside its source-derived amplitude envelope.\",\"license\":{\"detail\":\"\",\"href\":\"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/\",\"label\":\"CC BY-SA 4.0\"},\"provenance\":\"The OGG is the unchanged released mobile audition. Compatibility WAV: decoded with FFmpeg to 48 kHz stereo signed 16-bit PCM, without intentional gain, trimming or tempo changes. The waveform is a peak envelope across both decoded channels, normalized only for drawing; it is not a calibrated sound-pressure plot.\",\"source\":{\"detail\":\"Published manifest SHA-256 b38ace0c8e094c07640b54f76b35aa007a2c04954fa44e02ffa41154e7317f03. Selected source records and unchanged mobile recording verified.\",\"href\":\"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22151203\",\"label\":\"Cuntz Positiv · VAO 0.5.0-rc.2\"},\"sourceRealization\":\"urn:musixplora:4010243:cuntz-positiv:realization:sample:mobile:ged:036\",\"sourceSha256\":\"c5b4bb9e6e70d615df621b64a6052ca5bada5fa71666ea074423e7593389b104\",\"title\":\"A released Cuntz tone you can inspect\",\"type\":\"listening\",\"wav\":{\"byteSize\":1810766,\"sha256\":\"54151b1a2affd571c38ae4c613421b2ae4c3d42695cc178160d95176ab922155\",\"src\":\"/audio/cuntz-ged-036-pcm-54151b1a2affd571.wav\"},\"waveform\":[0.03277,0.18349,0.46003,0.56225,0.63368,0.65039,0.68021,0.70806,0.82143,0.70839,0.80963,0.78244,0.79784,0.79948,0.76835,0.79554,0.85059,0.84895,0.87516,1,0.92005,0.80537,0.80898,0.78539,0.80079,0.80832,0.79063,0.7962,0.80898,0.81455,0.76245,0.77097,0.72936,0.75164,0.77359,0.76311,0.85616,0.80996,0.74345,0.72051,0.70708,0.70806,0.73689,0.74476,0.77556,0.75197,0.73132,0.8329,0.78735,0.71691,0.75262,0.75197,0.75885,0.72215,0.69921,0.73591,0.73132,0.7536,0.82864,0.76474,0.7382,0.81913,0.80668,0.77195,0.73231,0.7002,0.7156,0.79292,0.75557,0.73427,0.81094,0.904,0.84862,0.7844,0.77457,0.81455,0.77916,0.77195,0.72117,0.68087,0.73198,0.76442,0.78702,0.93349,0.80144,0.85682,0.85288,0.87615,0.84862,0.81881,0.76999,0.80832,0.71756,0.75131,0.71068,0.77228,0.75066,0.78309,0.78932,0.79358,0.69397,0.79489,0.80767,0.80406,0.83716,0.87811,0.79817,0.75852,0.68578,0.76245,0.78473,0.78866,0.82438,0.76376,0.81225,0.76343,0.75524,0.75033,0.69102,0.71068,0.74902,0.73624,0.75098,0.7595,0.7595,0.67661,0.63139,0.33224,0.40957,0.23034,0.08421,0.05242,0.09731,0.1576,0.16121,0.154,0.17038,0.12484,0.07864,0.0118,0.00852,0.00393,0.0036,0.00491,0.0036,0.00459,0.00524,0.0036,0.00393,0.00623,0.01638,0.01016,0.02949,0.03145,0.01507,0.0059,0.01573,0.04817,0.05537,0.06094,0.0521,0.11959,0.15826,0.14744,0.04325,0.00754,0.00655,0.00819,0.04358,0.08781,0.08748,0.04817,0.11632,0.13106,0.09371,0.15858,0.14777,0.05472,0.00917,0.01606]},{\"id\":\"listening-interpret\",\"text\":\"Turn listening into a checkable observation\",\"type\":\"heading\"},{\"type\":\"visual\",\"visual\":{\"caption\":\"Follow the relationship between the things, then check the exact records in the workbench.\",\"layout\":\"flow\",\"nodes\":[{\"detail\":\"The published OGG bytes have a specific identity.\",\"icon\":\"file\",\"label\":\"File\",\"value\":\"Verified recording\"},{\"detail\":\"The thesis describes the recording setup.\",\"icon\":\"layers\",\"label\":\"Account\",\"value\":\"Acquisition context\"},{\"detail\":\"A statement needs its own evidence and limits.\",\"icon\":\"organ\",\"label\":\"Interpretation\",\"value\":\"A scoped observation\"}],\"relations\":[\"Encoding is distinct from acquisition\",\"A waveform supports amplitude observations, not every acoustic claim\"],\"title\":\"Separate the sound from the claim\"}},{\"text\":\"Describe what you observe before explaining its cause. “The displayed envelope changes during this file” is a narrower statement than “the organ’s wind supply is unstable”. A causal claim would need an appropriate measurement protocol, context and evidence. Keep that distinction visible when sharing a listening result.\",\"type\":\"p\"},{\"id\":\"listening-reuse\",\"text\":\"Reuse an attributed recording responsibly\",\"type\":\"heading\"},{\"items\":[\"Cite the fixed Cuntz version DOI and the selected realization identifier or file digest. Preserve the attribution and CC BY-SA 4.0 licence.\",\"Keep the unchanged source audition. Identify any conversion, crop, gain change or analysis derivative you create. The compatibility WAV here is explicitly described as a decoding and quantization derivative.\",\"Document your analysis or listening setup when it affects the result. Do not substitute an amplitude visualization for a calibrated acoustic measurement.\"],\"type\":\"list\"},{\"items\":[{\"detail\":\"A different evidence chain: result, workbook and timestamp qualification.\",\"href\":\"/notebooks/ontologies/cuntz/#cuntz-evidence-explorer\",\"label\":\"Follow the measurement evidence\"},{\"detail\":\"Auralization and evaluation boundaries.\",\"href\":\"/notebooks/vao/acoustics/\",\"label\":\"Understand the acoustic method\"},{\"detail\":\"Practise identities, checksums and carrier delivery.\",\"href\":\"/notebooks/vao/workbench/\",\"label\":\"Package your evidence\"}],\"type\":\"links\"}],\"intro\":\"Connect a released organ recording to its waveform, acquisition account and file identity. Learn to distinguish audible features from the historical and acoustic claims a recording can support.\",\"overview\":{\"summary\":\"Connect a released organ recording to its waveform, acquisition account and file identity. Learn to distinguish audible features from the historical and acoustic claims a recording can support.\",\"takeaway\":\"Start with the overview, follow the visual examples, then inspect the technical details and sources.\"},\"slug\":\"listening-study\",\"sources\":[{\"detail\":\"Published manifest SHA-256 b38ace0c8e094c07640b54f76b35aa007a2c04954fa44e02ffa41154e7317f03. Selected source records and unchanged mobile recording verified.\",\"href\":\"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22151203\",\"label\":\"Cuntz Positiv · VAO 0.5.0-rc.2\"},{\"detail\":\"Submitted dissertation, 11 September 2026; §8.2.2.1, printed pp. 264–265, and §8.4.1, printed pp. 275–282, describe Cuntz recording and digital analysis. Acquisition description is distinct from the encoded mobile derivative.\",\"label\":\"Dominik Ukolov · Musikinstrumente im virtuellen Raum (2026)\"},{\"detail\":\"Unmodified released reference validator, packer, schemas and minimal fixture. Software Apache 2.0; schemas and examples CC BY 4.0, Dominik Ukolov and contributors.\",\"href\":\"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22214248\",\"label\":\"VAO Standard 0.5.0\"}],\"title\":\"Listen to Cuntz, with the evidence in view\"},\"date\":\"2026-10-09\",\"edition\":\"2026-10-workbench\",\"figures\":{},\"glossary\":[{\"definition\":\"Material offered as grounds for a claim. Its relevance depends on the claim, context, transmission and interpretation.\",\"example\":{\"detail\":\"\",\"href\":\"/notebooks/ontologies/cuntz/#cuntz-measurement\",\"label\":\"Work through the Cuntz example\"},\"term\":\"Evidence\"},{\"definition\":\"The circumstances within which a statement applies, such as a historical configuration. Context is distinct from the history of how the statement was recorded.\",\"example\":{\"detail\":\"\",\"href\":\"/notebooks/ontologies/cuntz/#cuntz-time\",\"label\":\"Work through the Cuntz example\"},\"term\":\"Context\"}]}",
  "payload": {
    "edition": "2026-10-workbench",
    "date": "2026-10-09",
    "book": {
      "slug": "vao",
      "title": "Virtual Acoustic Objects",
      "number": "01"
    },
    "chapter": {
      "slug": "listening-study",
      "title": "Listen to Cuntz, with the evidence in view",
      "intro": "Connect a released organ recording to its waveform, acquisition account and file identity. Learn to distinguish audible features from the historical and acoustic claims a recording can support.",
      "sources": [
        {
          "label": "Cuntz Positiv · VAO 0.5.0-rc.2",
          "href": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22151203",
          "detail": "Published manifest SHA-256 b38ace0c8e094c07640b54f76b35aa007a2c04954fa44e02ffa41154e7317f03. Selected source records and unchanged mobile recording verified."
        },
        {
          "label": "Dominik Ukolov · Musikinstrumente im virtuellen Raum (2026)",
          "detail": "Submitted dissertation, 11 September 2026; §8.2.2.1, printed pp. 264–265, and §8.4.1, printed pp. 275–282, describe Cuntz recording and digital analysis. Acquisition description is distinct from the encoded mobile derivative."
        },
        {
          "label": "VAO Standard 0.5.0",
          "href": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22214248",
          "detail": "Unmodified released reference validator, packer, schemas and minimal fixture. Software Apache 2.0; schemas and examples CC BY 4.0, Dominik Ukolov and contributors."
        }
      ],
      "blocks": [
        {
          "type": "heading",
          "id": "listening-start",
          "text": "A recording, a representation and a research question"
        },
        {
          "type": "p",
          "text": "A listening example becomes reusable when someone else can identify the exact file, understand how it was obtained, and see the limits of the interpretation. Start with a short audition and its amplitude envelope, then inspect the source and encoding details."
        },
        {
          "type": "listening",
          "id": "cuntz-verified-listening",
          "title": "A released Cuntz tone you can inspect",
          "intro": "Listen to the Gedackt mobile audition for control-note 36. This full 9.43-second file is one selected recording from the collection, presented alongside its source-derived amplitude envelope.",
          "audio": {
            "src": "/audio/cuntz-ged-036-c5b4bb9e6e70d615.ogg",
            "sha256": "c5b4bb9e6e70d615df621b64a6052ca5bada5fa71666ea074423e7593389b104",
            "byteSize": 66378
          },
          "wav": {
            "src": "/audio/cuntz-ged-036-pcm-54151b1a2affd571.wav",
            "sha256": "54151b1a2affd571c38ae4c613421b2ae4c3d42695cc178160d95176ab922155",
            "byteSize": 1810766
          },
          "waveform": [
            0.03277,
            0.18349,
            0.46003,
            0.56225,
            0.63368,
            0.65039,
            0.68021,
            0.70806,
            0.82143,
            0.70839,
            0.80963,
            0.78244,
            0.79784,
            0.79948,
            0.76835,
            0.79554,
            0.85059,
            0.84895,
            0.87516,
            1,
            0.92005,
            0.80537,
            0.80898,
            0.78539,
            0.80079,
            0.80832,
            0.79063,
            0.7962,
            0.80898,
            0.81455,
            0.76245,
            0.77097,
            0.72936,
            0.75164,
            0.77359,
            0.76311,
            0.85616,
            0.80996,
            0.74345,
            0.72051,
            0.70708,
            0.70806,
            0.73689,
            0.74476,
            0.77556,
            0.75197,
            0.73132,
            0.8329,
            0.78735,
            0.71691,
            0.75262,
            0.75197,
            0.75885,
            0.72215,
            0.69921,
            0.73591,
            0.73132,
            0.7536,
            0.82864,
            0.76474,
            0.7382,
            0.81913,
            0.80668,
            0.77195,
            0.73231,
            0.7002,
            0.7156,
            0.79292,
            0.75557,
            0.73427,
            0.81094,
            0.904,
            0.84862,
            0.7844,
            0.77457,
            0.81455,
            0.77916,
            0.77195,
            0.72117,
            0.68087,
            0.73198,
            0.76442,
            0.78702,
            0.93349,
            0.80144,
            0.85682,
            0.85288,
            0.87615,
            0.84862,
            0.81881,
            0.76999,
            0.80832,
            0.71756,
            0.75131,
            0.71068,
            0.77228,
            0.75066,
            0.78309,
            0.78932,
            0.79358,
            0.69397,
            0.79489,
            0.80767,
            0.80406,
            0.83716,
            0.87811,
            0.79817,
            0.75852,
            0.68578,
            0.76245,
            0.78473,
            0.78866,
            0.82438,
            0.76376,
            0.81225,
            0.76343,
            0.75524,
            0.75033,
            0.69102,
            0.71068,
            0.74902,
            0.73624,
            0.75098,
            0.7595,
            0.7595,
            0.67661,
            0.63139,
            0.33224,
            0.40957,
            0.23034,
            0.08421,
            0.05242,
            0.09731,
            0.1576,
            0.16121,
            0.154,
            0.17038,
            0.12484,
            0.07864,
            0.0118,
            0.00852,
            0.00393,
            0.0036,
            0.00491,
            0.0036,
            0.00459,
            0.00524,
            0.0036,
            0.00393,
            0.00623,
            0.01638,
            0.01016,
            0.02949,
            0.03145,
            0.01507,
            0.0059,
            0.01573,
            0.04817,
            0.05537,
            0.06094,
            0.0521,
            0.11959,
            0.15826,
            0.14744,
            0.04325,
            0.00754,
            0.00655,
            0.00819,
            0.04358,
            0.08781,
            0.08748,
            0.04817,
            0.11632,
            0.13106,
            0.09371,
            0.15858,
            0.14777,
            0.05472,
            0.00917,
            0.01606
          ],
          "duration": 9.430666666666667,
          "source": {
            "label": "Cuntz Positiv · VAO 0.5.0-rc.2",
            "href": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22151203",
            "detail": "Published manifest SHA-256 b38ace0c8e094c07640b54f76b35aa007a2c04954fa44e02ffa41154e7317f03. Selected source records and unchanged mobile recording verified."
          },
          "sourceRealization": "urn:musixplora:4010243:cuntz-positiv:realization:sample:mobile:ged:036",
          "sourceSha256": "c5b4bb9e6e70d615df621b64a6052ca5bada5fa71666ea074423e7593389b104",
          "attribution": "Recording, data curation, VAO production and maintenance: Dominik Ukolov; measurements: Philipp Hosbach; TASTEN and DISKOS coordination: Dr. Heike Fricke; project leadership: Prof. Dr. Josef Focht; restoration: Markus Brosig and Veit Heller; institution: Leipzig University; hosting: Musikinstrumentenmuseum der Universität Leipzig.",
          "license": {
            "label": "CC BY-SA 4.0",
            "href": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/",
            "detail": ""
          },
          "provenance": "The OGG is the unchanged released mobile audition. Compatibility WAV: decoded with FFmpeg to 48 kHz stereo signed 16-bit PCM, without intentional gain, trimming or tempo changes. The waveform is a peak envelope across both decoded channels, normalized only for drawing; it is not a calibrated sound-pressure plot.",
          "context": "The dissertation describes acquisition at 192 kHz / 24 bit using a Neumann KM184 pair and RME Babyface Pro. This selected released mobile realization is Vorbis OGG at 48 kHz, stereo; its declared source master is a 192 kHz floating-point WAVE file. These encoding descriptions do not change the acquisition account.",
          "boundary": "This is a recorded, encoded audition, not a certified reconstruction of how the organ sounded in 1610. Your playback device and room affect what you hear. The waveform is not calibrated sound pressure; it cannot establish acoustic fidelity, historical tuning, or the unresolved mapping between the physical and digital register inventories."
        },
        {
          "type": "heading",
          "id": "listening-interpret",
          "text": "Turn listening into a checkable observation"
        },
        {
          "type": "visual",
          "visual": {
            "layout": "flow",
            "title": "Separate the sound from the claim",
            "caption": "Follow the relationship between the things, then check the exact records in the workbench.",
            "nodes": [
              {
                "label": "File",
                "value": "Verified recording",
                "detail": "The published OGG bytes have a specific identity.",
                "icon": "file"
              },
              {
                "label": "Account",
                "value": "Acquisition context",
                "detail": "The thesis describes the recording setup.",
                "icon": "layers"
              },
              {
                "label": "Interpretation",
                "value": "A scoped observation",
                "detail": "A statement needs its own evidence and limits.",
                "icon": "organ"
              }
            ],
            "relations": [
              "Encoding is distinct from acquisition",
              "A waveform supports amplitude observations, not every acoustic claim"
            ]
          }
        },
        {
          "type": "p",
          "text": "Describe what you observe before explaining its cause. “The displayed envelope changes during this file” is a narrower statement than “the organ’s wind supply is unstable”. A causal claim would need an appropriate measurement protocol, context and evidence. Keep that distinction visible when sharing a listening result."
        },
        {
          "type": "heading",
          "id": "listening-reuse",
          "text": "Reuse an attributed recording responsibly"
        },
        {
          "type": "list",
          "items": [
            "Cite the fixed Cuntz version DOI and the selected realization identifier or file digest. Preserve the attribution and CC BY-SA 4.0 licence.",
            "Keep the unchanged source audition. Identify any conversion, crop, gain change or analysis derivative you create. The compatibility WAV here is explicitly described as a decoding and quantization derivative.",
            "Document your analysis or listening setup when it affects the result. Do not substitute an amplitude visualization for a calibrated acoustic measurement."
          ]
        },
        {
          "type": "links",
          "items": [
            {
              "label": "Follow the measurement evidence",
              "href": "/notebooks/ontologies/cuntz/#cuntz-evidence-explorer",
              "detail": "A different evidence chain: result, workbook and timestamp qualification."
            },
            {
              "label": "Understand the acoustic method",
              "href": "/notebooks/vao/acoustics/",
              "detail": "Auralization and evaluation boundaries."
            },
            {
              "label": "Package your evidence",
              "href": "/notebooks/vao/workbench/",
              "detail": "Practise identities, checksums and carrier delivery."
            }
          ]
        }
      ],
      "overview": {
        "summary": "Connect a released organ recording to its waveform, acquisition account and file identity. Learn to distinguish audible features from the historical and acoustic claims a recording can support.",
        "takeaway": "Start with the overview, follow the visual examples, then inspect the technical details and sources."
      }
    },
    "glossary": [
      {
        "term": "Evidence",
        "definition": "Material offered as grounds for a claim. Its relevance depends on the claim, context, transmission and interpretation.",
        "example": {
          "label": "Work through the Cuntz example",
          "href": "/notebooks/ontologies/cuntz/#cuntz-measurement",
          "detail": ""
        }
      },
      {
        "term": "Context",
        "definition": "The circumstances within which a statement applies, such as a historical configuration. Context is distinct from the history of how the statement was recorded.",
        "example": {
          "label": "Work through the Cuntz example",
          "href": "/notebooks/ontologies/cuntz/#cuntz-time",
          "detail": ""
        }
      }
    ],
    "figures": {}
  }
}